Photo: Mdiafarm

Seat belt reminders and black boxes give most safety 

Twenty-one safety technologies have been assessed to find out which give most safety for the money. Seat belt reminders and event and accident data recorders top the list according to a new analysis from COWI.
Seat belt reminders and event and accident data recorders that can show the speed of a car and the actions taken by a driver in accident situations top the list of vehicle safety equipment for cars and trucks.

The analysis also shows that there is considerable potential in alcolocks, electronic stability control (ESC) and intelligent speed adaptation, according to the results of an economic cost-benefit assessment carried out by COWI on behalf of the EU.

The analysis shows which technology "gives most safety for the money".
Photo: Mediafarm


Under development

COWI team leader Thomas Odgaard explains: "With very many of the 21 technologies that we have analysed, the benefits far outweigh the costs. However, for some technologies it was not possible to carry out the analysis in its entirety, as these technologies are still in the test phase or under development."

"Although this does not mean that they are not effective or suitable as safety equipment, because they could well prove to be."

Of the 21 technologies analysed, it was possible to carry out cost-benefit assessments for 13 of them.

Reduce fatalities by half

The analysis is carried out on behalf of the EU which has set itself the goal of halving the number of road fatalities by the year 2010, in part through the use of passive and active safety equipment in vehicles.

In 2001, over 50,000 people lost their lives and millions were injured as a result of road accidents in Europe. Apart from the human cost, the socio-economic costs run to 229 billion € annually.

Demand for safety

Countries beyond the EU, too, are looking at ways to improve safety in cars. And motorists themselves are increasingly weighing safety measures when deciding which car to buy.

"Clearly this constitutes a competitive parameter that car producers are already working on. And all the indications are that it will take on even more importance in the future. Normally, new technologies first appear in more expensive cars and later they become standard in other classes of cars," says Morten Klintø Hansen, traffic safety expert with COWI.

By Gitte Roe Eriksen, cht@cowi.com  
Published: 8.5.2006